Graphic designer Eli has harbored a secret crush on nerdy math teacher Lincoln since they were at school together, and he's perfectly content with his unrequited feelings-until Lincoln requests a special handmade holiday gift: a dating profile with all the bells and whistles Eli can include, one that will be sure to find Lincoln a boyfriend for Christmas. Eli uses building the profile as an excuse to spend time with Lincoln, but will he be able to watch his friend find love with someone else?